ไทย

Articles

What Are ICP-MS and AAS? How Laboratories Test Heavy Metals, and How They Differ From Field Test Kits

ICP-MS and AAS are the main instruments laboratories use to test for heavy metals in water. ICP-MS uses a very hot plasma to turn elements into ions and then sorts and counts them by mass, so it can measure many elements at once at very low levels. AAS, or atomic absorption spectroscopy (also called atomic absorption spectrometry), measures how much light the atoms of a metal "absorb." It usually measures one element at a time and comes in several forms suited to different metals. Both are reference methods for confirming results and issuing official reports. This article explains how each instrument works, how to prepare water samples for heavy metal analysis, and how the laboratory's role differs from that of field test kits.

3D illustration of the path of a water sample from a riverbank, onto a transport vehicle, to a central laboratory building

Why heavy metal testing in water needs specialized instruments

Heavy metals in drinking water can be harmful even in very small amounts. Thailand's Department of Health criteria for drinkable tap water (2020) set arsenic at no more than 0.01 milligrams per liter, lead at no more than 0.01 milligrams per liter, cadmium at no more than 0.003 milligrams per liter, and mercury at no more than 0.001 milligrams per liter. In smaller units, 0.01 milligrams per liter of arsenic equals 10 ppb, or about 10 parts per billion. (For more on units, see What are ppm and ppb?)

Measuring such small amounts reliably requires very sensitive instruments, systems to correct for interference, and quality control of the analysis at every step. This is why the laboratory is still the reference method, even though field test kits have become much easier to use.

What is ICP-MS?

ICP-MS stands for Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry. In plain terms, it is "measuring the mass of elements using a plasma." The US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) has a standard method for testing elements in water by ICP-MS, Method 200.8, which covers 21 elements, including arsenic, lead, cadmium and mercury, in groundwater, surface water and drinking water.

How ICP-MS works

According to the description in that standard method, measurement has four main stages:

  1. Nebulization. The prepared water sample is sprayed into a fine mist and carried into the plasma.
  2. Ionization in the plasma. The plasma is argon gas energized by radio frequency until it is extremely hot. Inside it, the water evaporates, substances break down into atoms, and the atoms lose electrons and become ions.
  3. Separation by mass. The ions are drawn through a vacuum interface into a mass analyzer, which sorts them by their "mass-to-charge ratio." Each element has its own mass, so they can be separated.
  4. Counting ions. The detector counts the ions at each mass. The more ions counted, the more of that element is present. The count is then compared with standards to calculate a concentration.

Picture an automatic coin sorter that drops coins into slots by weight and counts how many land in each slot. ICP-MS does the same with the ions of elements.

ICP-MS strengths and limitations

ICP-OES, a close relative of ICP-MS

Many laboratories also have ICP-OES (Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry). It uses the same kind of plasma, but instead of sorting ions by mass, it measures "the light that elements emit" when excited in the plasma. Each element emits light at its own wavelengths. ICP-OES can also measure many elements at once; the US EPA standard method for water is Method 200.7. Laboratories choose ICP-OES or ICP-MS according to the element and the concentration range to be measured. A community water study in Khon Kaen, Thailand, by the NANOTEC research team and colleagues used AAS, ICP-MS and ICP-OES in accredited laboratories.

What is AAS (atomic absorption spectroscopy)?

AAS stands for Atomic Absorption Spectrometry, often searched as atomic absorption spectroscopy: "measuring the light absorbed by atoms." It is a technique laboratories have used to test metals for a long time.

How AAS works

US EPA Method 7000B describes the principle as follows:

  1. Atomization. The sample is drawn into a flame, and the heat breaks the metal down into free atoms.
  2. Element-specific light. A special lamp (hollow cathode lamp) emits light at the wavelength specific to the metal being measured, and this light passes through the flame.
  3. Measuring the missing light. Atoms of that metal absorb light of this wavelength. The more atoms there are, the less light reaches the detector. The amount of light absorbed therefore indicates the metal's concentration.

Think of shining a flashlight of one particular color through fog. If the fog contains a lot of a substance that "eats" that color, the light coming out the other side is dimmer. Because each color of light works for only one metal, AAS usually measures one element at a time and the lamp is changed for each element.

AAS comes in several forms, chosen by metal

Flame AAS works well for many metals at concentrations that are not very low. To measure lower levels, the standard method recommends specialized forms:

The WHO background document on arsenic in drinking water states that GF-AAS, HG-AAS and ICP-MS are more sensitive than other methods for arsenic. For more on arsenic, see What is arsenic?

ICP-MS vs AAS and other laboratory instruments compared

Instrument What it measures Elements per analysis Commonly used for
ICP-MS Number of ions sorted by mass Many at once Many heavy metals at very low levels, including arsenic, lead, cadmium
ICP-OES Light emitted by elements in the plasma Many at once Many elements in water, chosen by concentration range
Flame AAS Light absorbed by atoms in a flame One at a time Metals at concentrations that are not very low
GF-AAS (graphite furnace) Light absorbed by atoms in a graphite tube One at a time Lead, cadmium at low levels
HG-AAS (hydride generation) Light absorbed after conversion to a gas One at a time Arsenic
CV-AAS (cold vapor) Light absorbed by mercury vapor Mercury only Mercury

All the methods in this table are standard instruments. The choice depends on the metal, the level to be measured, the number of samples, and the instruments each laboratory has.

3D illustration of six clear water sample vials standing in a rack

Sending water samples to a laboratory: what to prepare

Good results start with good samples. If a sample is collected the wrong way, even the most sensitive instrument will give a result that does not reflect the real water. Key points:

  1. Contact the laboratory before sampling. Ask what bottles to use, how much water is needed, and how samples must be stored. Many laboratories provide bottles, because they must be clean and metal-free.
  2. Be clear about what you want to know. Do you want "total metals in the water" or "only the dissolved part"? The two are prepared differently. Under Method 200.8, if only the dissolved part is wanted, the sample must be filtered through a 0.45-micrometer filter at the time of collection or as soon as possible afterward.
  3. Acid preservation. Samples for metals usually need nitric acid added to bring the pH below 2, so metals do not stick to the bottle walls or settle out. The same standard method says the acid can be added in the field or on arrival at the laboratory. Concentrated acid is dangerous; follow only the instructions of the laboratory doing the testing.
  4. Label and record. Note the sampling point, date, time and the person who collected the sample, so the sample can be traced.
  5. Field blank. Work that needs high confidence may include a "blank": pure water put in the same kind of bottle with the same acid and sent along with the samples, to check that the bottles or acid did not add metals.

What does ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation mean for a laboratory?

ISO/IEC 17025 is the international standard for general requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. The current edition is from 2017. It looks at technical competence, impartiality and consistent operation, so that test results can be trusted.

What to know when choosing a laboratory:

How the laboratory differs from field test kits

Laboratories and field test kits do not compete; they work at different stages.

Laboratory (ICP-MS, AAS) Electrochemical field test kit Colorimetric test kit
Result Confirmatory number Number at the sampling point Range of values from a color comparison
Where tested In the laboratory; samples must be transported At the water source, with a reader At the water source; no electricity needed
Strengths Most accurate and sensitive, with quality control; the reference method Fast numbers, several metals at once, can retest often Easy to use, portable, can test many points
Limitations Wait for results; specialized instruments and experts Needs good sample preparation and calibration; used for screening Usually one substance at a time; read by eye
Role Confirmation, official reports Screening and monitoring Broad screening

In practice, field test kits help answer "which points look suspicious and should be sent for testing," while the laboratory answers "what is the true value, usable as a reference." This division of work lets laboratory resources go to the samples that matter most. For an overview of all three methods, see How many ways are there to test water quality?, and for the principle of field sensors, see What is an electrochemical sensor?

How M-Sense helps

M-Sense is a portable test kit for heavy metal contamination in water that uses an electrochemical technique. It was developed by the National Nanotechnology Center (NANOTEC), NSTDA, under the A-QUALITY program. It tests for four metals: arsenic, lead, cadmium and mercury. It reports results as numbers from ppb to ppm, and a test takes about 5 minutes, so it suits the screening and monitoring stage at the sampling point.

M-Sense does not replace the laboratory; the two work together. M-Sense was field-tested with the Regional Environment and Pollution Control Office 1 (Chiang Mai) in the Kok River basin in northern Thailand, compared against standard laboratory methods, and the results were consistent. Suspicious results are still sent for confirmation with standard laboratory methods. See the metals it detects and their criteria on What it detects and the criteria, and real-world use on Field use.

Frequently asked questions

ICP-MS vs AAS: which is better? Neither is better in every case. ICP-MS measures many elements at once at very low levels. AAS measures one element at a time, but has specialized forms that are sensitive for certain metals, such as HG-AAS for arsenic and CV-AAS for mercury. Laboratories choose according to the metal and the level to be measured.

What kind of test is AAS, and can it be used for drinking water? AAS measures how much light of a specific wavelength the atoms of a metal absorb. It can test metals in water, including drinking water, by choosing the form that suits the metal and the level to be measured.

Which method do laboratories use for arsenic in water? The WHO background document states that GF-AAS, HG-AAS and ICP-MS are more sensitive than other methods for arsenic in drinking water. Each laboratory may use a different method; check the method stated in the report.

Why is acid added to the sample bottle? To keep the metals dissolved in the water, so they do not stick to the bottle walls or settle out while waiting for analysis. The standard method requires a pH below 2, but acid is dangerous, so follow the instructions of the laboratory doing the testing.

Field test kit and laboratory results don't match exactly. Which should I trust? Use the laboratory result as the reference when a decision is needed. Results can differ because of the measurement principle, sensitivity, interferences and different sampling times. Field test kits are there to help with screening and tracking trends.

Laboratory results exceed the criteria. What next? Inform the agency responsible for the water source or water supply in the area so it can decide how to deal with it. If you are worried about your health, contact a subdistrict health promoting hospital (the local primary care unit) or the local public health office.

Does your agency need to screen for heavy metals before sending samples to a laboratory?

Ask NANOTEC · See how agencies can request it · How M-Sense works

References

NANOTEC, NSTDA assistantAnswers are based on NANOTEC information. Questions it cannot answer are passed to the team.

Privacy policy

The M-Sense website and its question-answering assistant are operated on behalf of the National Nanotechnology Center (NANOTEC), NSTDA.

Data collected: the messages you type in the chat and the contact details you enter yourself, such as name, organization, position, province, phone number and email. If you chat through LINE, the system sees your LINE display name and profile picture.

Used for: answering questions, passing your request to the NANOTEC team, contacting you back and improving the answers. Not used for other marketing, and never sold.

Automatic answers are generated by an artificial intelligence system, so chat messages are processed by AI and cloud service providers, which may be located outside Thailand.

Who sees the data: NANOTEC staff who handle inquiries and the website administrators.

You can ask to see, correct or delete your data through the "Ask NANOTEC" button or LINE @nanotec.